Like a lot of fans of Fantasy literature, and especially of the Epic Fantasy subgenre, I grew up on what today you might call “Tolkienesque” fantasy. You likely know what I mean: Dragons and Elves and Fairies and Wizards and Magic Swords and Hidden Heirs and Noble Destinies. I could take a year off your life just by linking to the relevant “TV Tropes” pages. (Don’t worry, I won’t do that do you. I love you too much. You can get lost all by yourself if that’s your inclination. Oh ye gods, I almost got lost myself just by linking the home page!)
One of the first fantasy novels I ever read was Lloyd Alexander’s The Book of Three, the first in his “Prydain Chronicles”. It wasn’t much longer before I’d read Tolkien and Dragonlance and a slew of other Tolkienian fantasy works. Although Tolkien’s “Lord of the Rings” trilogy didn’t feature all of the major tropes and archetypes we now associate with fantasy of this type, his work was nonetheless so seminal in the foundations of this genre that we now consider him to be arch-progenitor of the form and genre, even if some of these tropes actually predate him.
And yet, it’s all the fashion and rage, these days, to dismiss Tolkienesque-style Epic Fantasy, to bemoan the woeful and backward state of the genre, and to denounce as tired, and trite and boring all of these old tropes. Most of the big names in modern Fantasy Literature make a big deal about how about how they’re not writing Tolkienesque Fantasy. When Brandon Sanderson’s The Way of Kings came out he wrote an essay called “Postmodernism in Fantasy” (and got a lot of attention in the blogosphere grumbling that he’d misused the term “postmodernism”), he was essentially making this point. Perhaps what Brandon was really talking about wasn’t Postmodern Fantasy. Perhaps what he was really talking about was, to coin a phrase, Post-Tolkien Fantasy.
To hear the Post-Tolkienists talk, the world of fantasy has heretofore been nothing but a sad and endless stream of cheap Tolkien knock-offs and drudgery. But at last, they promise, there will be an end to this otherwise endless tide of backward fantasy literature. At last, they will create something new, something that challenges the old, familiar tropes. At last, we will shed the shackles of Tolkienism!
Me… I don’t think that way. Continue reading