There’s a lot of bad logic out there. In the debate between those advocating for digital self-publishing and those advocating for traditional publishing… there’s more than a fair share of bad logic.
I was intrigued by this infographic on “Rhetological Fallacies” recently linked on a daily link roundup of one author I follow. These are argument logic errors. So, keep that in mind as a basis for where I’m going next.
I get around on the internet, occasionally. I follow a lot of blogs – some more closely than others. That’s background. It is, therefore, that I happened upon a blog post by aspiring author Tom Simon. I’d followed a few of his posts before, ostensibly because something he posted once interested me. But this one, in particular, smacked me as… well… Keep that link on Rhetological Fallacies in mind, will you?
Mr. Simon does a lot of posts with short quotes from various things he finds interesting. Often, he’ll indicate that some quote or another is, in his estimation,wise.
The alleged wisdom in this recent post goes back to another comment on a recent Passive Voice blog post.
On the subject of whether to publish traditionally or to digitally self-published, the quoted sage said this:
My attitude is to look at what happens if you make the wrong choice.
If you self-publish and you do something wrong, you can fix it. If the entire self-publishing industry implodes, you still have the rights to your work, so you can still go sell it to a traditional publisher.
If you go traditional and something goes wrong, you are completely screwed. You’ve signed away your rights, you don’t have control over how your work is marketed, etc., etc. If your publisher goes under, it’s going to take a long time and a lot of legal work for you to be able to re-sell that work, assuming you ever can. Is it worth to you to take that kind of risk in return for some editing and cover art?
If this is what passes for wisdom… I must weep.
Where do I begin? Well… that’s easy enough: I’ll begin at the beginning. And when I get to the end, I’ll stop. Continue reading